Club honours of Atherstone United and Town.

Atherstone United

1981-82 - West Midland League Division 1 champions, West Midland League Division 1 Cup winners
1983-84 - Walsall Senior Cup winners
1985-86 - West Midland League Premier Division Cup winners
1986-87 - Banks's Brewery League Premier Division winners, Banks's Brewery League Premier Division Cup winners
1988-89 - Beazer Homes League Midlands Division runners-up
1989-90 - Birmingham Senior Cup runners-up

Best FA Cup run: 1990-91 2nd round v Crewe Alexandra

Record Attendance: 1987-88, 2,816 v VS Rugby, FA Cup replay

Record win: 1986-87 12-2 home v Tipton Town Banks's Brewery League Premier Division

Most goals in a game: 31-10-81, six by Alan Bourton v Donnington Wood

Since club reformed in 2004 as Atherstone Town

2004-05: Midland Combination Division 1 champions, President's Cup winners
2005-06: Midland Combination Premier Division champions, Birmingham County FA Midweek Cup winners, Endsleigh Challenge Cup winners. Record goals scored in a season Roy Dunkley - 77.
2007-08 Midland Football Alliance champions, Alliance Manager of the Year (Jimmy Ginnelly)
2008-09 J. McGorian Cup winners (Alliance champs v League Cup winners), Southern League Cup winners, Southern League Midlands 1 play-offs